Reviving Speakeasy Tactics: Indiana's Cigarette Tax Increase

Indiana's latest hike in cigarette taxes represents more than a fiscal strategy; it echoes the historical clandestine commerce of the bootlegging era. As the state increases its cigarette prices per pack, lawmakers enforce stringent penalties, reminiscent of the Prohibition era, aiming to curb modern-day smugglers.

The atmosphere is uncannily similar to the 1930s when Indiana's efforts targeted illicit alcohol and tobacco operations. Today, however, modern contraband flows through interstate highways and shopping centers, where consumers cross state lines to capitalize on lower taxes.

Kentucky and Tennessee provide valuable lessons. Kentucky, with its minimal cigarette tax of just 10 cents per pack compared to Indiana's $1, has been a notorious export hub, while Tennessee experienced increased bootlegging following its tax hikes in the early 2000s, echoing the smuggling patterns of yesteryears.

A January 2018 study by Johns Hopkins Bloomberg revealed that, despite fears of increased smuggling, states raising cigarette taxes by over 50 cents have seen notable revenue growth. Indiana's 2007 increase resulted in a substantial 43% rise in revenue, illustrating a complex narrative beyond the apparent resurgence of smuggling.

Enforcement and Financial Impact

Beginning July 1, Indiana more than doubles its cigarette tax, complemented by robust law enforcement measures:

Criminalization of out-of-state bulk buys, turning contraband into a felony offense.
Enhanced task forces, comprising Excise and state police, are stationed at toll points and warehouses to monitor shipments.
Regular audits of wholesalers and retailers aim to intercept counterfeit stamps.
The initiative is projected to channel $290 million annually towards public health funding.

Cross-Border Smuggling Dynamics

The primary challenge remains effective enforcement. Indiana's geographical proximity to states with lower taxes, such as Kentucky, poses a perpetual threat of illicit trade. A Tax Foundation report placed Indiana among the top states anticipated to witness increases in cigarette smuggling, citing substantial risks of consumer evasion and gray market sales.

Ohio, with its moderate cigarette tax and extensive highway system, is another concern. As revealed in a 2024 Mackinac Center study, up to 12% of Indiana's cigarettes may come from out-of-state purchases post-hike.

Strategies from Illinois and New York

Illinois:

Have Questions?

Let's talk. We are here to help!

Illinois has recently increased nicotine taxes to 45% of the wholesale price, fostering smuggling risks.
An estimated 30% of cigarettes consumed are smuggled across borders.
Strict penalties exist for unstamped packs—$20–$25 fines per package over nine. The state targets high-volume shipments following the 2019 tax raise, which triggered contraband hikes.

New York:

With one of the highest combined tax rates in the U.S., New York's smuggling rates exceed 50%, spiking to 61% after a recent tax increase.
The enforcement of felony-level trafficking laws, monitored by the Albany Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco & Firearms and state Tax Enforcement, acts on large-scale violations (Class D/E felonies for 10,000+ cigarettes).

Hoosier History Revived

Bootlegging has deep roots in Indiana's economy. The Prohibition era saw southern counties like Lawrence becoming notorious for moonshining activities. Illegal alcohol moved via "Whiskey Roads"; today, cigarette cartons are the modern contraband substitute.

As history echoes through the corridors of Indiana's current fiscal policies, the medium may have shifted from bottles to packs, but strategies remain akin — exploiting legal gaps through geographic and tactical advantages.

Former Excise officer John Halverson draws parallels, stating, “We’ve moved from barn stills to cartons in car trunks, yet the essence endures.”

A Health Triumph or a Gamble?

While critics argue smuggling weakens policy, health advocates maintain that even partial tax compliance leads to significant declines in smoking, particularly among youth and low-income demographics.

Mike Seilback of the American Lung Association commented to The Indiana Capital Chronicle, “Increased tobacco prices are proven to dramatically curb smoking. We anticipate vast numbers of quitters and, hopefully, a dip in beginners.”

Despite smuggling potentially affecting 10–30% of sales, research suggests states can see net revenue boosts post-tax enhancements with robust enforcement. Indiana's 2007 experience echoes this: sales dropped 41%, yet revenues climbed 43%.

Future Implications

Indiana wagers heavily on this directive’s success. The actual results hinge on achieving deterrence without stifling small businesses while staying ahead of savvy contraband operatives.

Only time can unravel the true outcomes, but for now, the state channels the bootlegging era's adventurous spirit. The stakes are elevated, modes upgraded, yet the fiscal and regulatory game remains enduring as Indiana itself.

Have Questions?

Let's talk. We are here to help!

Share this article...

Facebook

Twitter WhatsApp LinkedIn Pinterest Pocket Reddit Email

Sign up for our newsletter.

Each month, we will send you a roundup of our latest blog content covering the tax and accounting tips & insights you need to know.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .

We care about the protection of your data.