Tax Implications of Being Scammed: What You Need to Know
Navigating the tax implications associated with scams and theft losses can be challenging, especially in light of legislative changes that restrict casualty and theft loss deductions primarily to those tied to disasters. Fortunately, for scam victims, some tax avenues remain viable.
Historically, tax law allowed for the deduction of theft losses not covered by insurance. Though recent legislative changes have limited such deductions, particularly for those unrelated to federally declared disasters, opportunities persist. Specifically, if scammed during a transaction with a profit motive, deductions may remain feasible.
According to Internal Revenue Code Section 165(c)(2), losses incurred from profit-motivated activities might qualify for deductions. This provision ensures that if your financial loss stems from a scam linked to a profit-driven endeavor, you may be able to claim tax relief, even in the absence of disaster designation. Recognizing this exception can offer indispensable financial respite from losses incurred due to scams.
Eligibility Criteria for Profit-Motivated Casualty Losses: To qualify as a deduction under the profit-motivated exception, several strict criteria must be met:
Profit Motive: The transaction must primarily aim to achieve economic gain. The IRS requires undeniable proof of bona fide profit expectations with substantial documentation backing this claim. Case law and IRS rulings emphasize the need for this determination.
Type of Transaction: Eligible transactions often involve traditional investment mediums such as securities, real estate, or other income-producing activities. Transactions lacking a profit motive typically fall outside deductible loss parameters.
Nature of Loss: The loss must directly relate to the profit-oriented transaction, demonstrated through financial records and legal documents. For example, investment scams targeting taxpayer investments may qualify if the profit intent requirement is met.
IRS Guidance Application: Claiming these deductions usually involves consulting IRS memoranda and rulings for definitions of deductible loss scenarios. A recent IRS Chief Counsel Memorandum (CCM 202511015) highlights potential deductible situations:
Investment Scams: Although fraudulent, losses from these incidents can qualify as deductible if the initial investment was made with a credible expectation of profit. Verify transaction legitimacy and profit intent with evidence like scammer communications, investment contracts, and monetary transfer proofs.
Theft Losses: Profit-driven theft is scrutinized separately; eligible losses must stem from profit-seeking transactions—not personal engagements.
Unfavorable Tax Implications: Losing IRA or tax-deferred pension funds to scams triggers significant tax concerns, dependent on whether the account is traditional or Roth.
For traditional IRAs or tax-deferred retirement plans, funds withdrawn prematurely during scams are taxable income. This can escalate taxable income, increasing tax liability and possibly resulting in a 10% early withdrawal penalty if the account holder is under 59½ years old.
Conversely, Roth IRA or Roth plan withdrawals face fewer immediate tax repercussions, as contributions utilize after-tax dollars. Assuming the account meets the five-year holding rule, contributions can typically be withdrawn without taxes or penalties. However, withdrawn earnings not used for qualifying reasons may face taxes and penalties.
The examples below illustrate qualifying scenarios for casualty losses and corresponding tax implications.
Example 1: Impersonator Scam - Qualifying Personal Casualty Loss
Taxpayer 1 fell victim to an impersonation scam. A “fraud specialist” falsely instructed tax-saving transfers for account protection. Unfortunately, the offshore accounts were controlled by the scammer.
Taxpayer 1’s primary intent to protect and reinvest showcases profit-oriented motives. Thus, this scenario qualifies as a theft loss for tax purposes due to its financial gain objectives.
Tax Implications:
a. Deductions are possible if itemizing on Schedule A.
b. Unfortunately, tax on traditional IRA distributions applies, including taxation on non-IRA account gains/losses. Additionally, if under age 59.5, a 10% early distribution penalty applies to traditional IRAs.
c. Rolling funds back into the IRA within 60 days exempts these provisions proportionally.
Example 2: Romance Scam - Non-Qualifying Personal Casualty Loss
Taxpayer 2 engaged in a romance scam and transferred funds overseas. Losses do not qualify for deductions, meeting only personal motives.
In this example, motivations lacked financial investment intent, disqualifying loss deductions under personal casualty loss regulations absent disaster declarations or sufficient personal casualty gains.
Tax Implications:
a. Casualty loss deductions are not permitted.
b. Traditional IRA distributions are taxable, recognizing gains/losses on non-IRA accounts surfaces. Similar penalties apply for traditional IRA early distribution.
c. Any restored IRA funds within 60 days negate issues per equivalent value.
Example 3: Kidnapping Scam - Non-Qualifying Personal Casualty Loss
Taxpayer 3 responded to a phishing attempt to save a “kidnapped” family member, transferring funds under duress. Similar to example 2, deductions are disallowed without profit motive.
Tax Implications: Identical to example 2.
Conclusion: These instances underscore the importance of evaluating transaction intent and nature to determine deductible scam-associated losses. Internal documentation supporting profit motives and detailed record-keeping may support future deduction eligibility claims.
Documentation and Intent: Clearly documenting investment context helps illustrate profit motive for future claims.
Scrutiny and Compliance: Heightened IRS scrutiny requires careful compliance, as auditors assess qualifying losses meticulously.
Prompt consultations upon encountering suspicious emails and texts—before fund transfers—can yield fraud detection and prevention insights. Educating family, especially seniors, about scams may prevent these unfortunate incidents. Encourage open communication for assistance to protect against financial loss and to provide support, ensuring asset security and peace of mind.
Sign up for our newsletter.
Each month, we will send you a roundup of our latest blog content covering the tax and accounting tips & insights you need to know.
We care about the protection of your data.